Baitcaster Vs Spinning Reel – Which one to Choose?

In today's article, we look at the pros and cons of a baitcaster vs spinning reel setup so you can make an informed decision on which is the best one for your needs.

spinning reel vs baitcaster reel

Fishing is a lot more fun when you’ve got the right equipment. While at one time, a basic hook and line was the standard, these days there are many more sophisticated tools and accessories which make your fishing trip even simpler and more enjoyable.

Two of those accessories you might want to consider are a spinning reel and a baitcaster. But, how do you choose between them? 

Some of the links below are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, we may make a commission if you click through and make a purchase.

Baitcaster or Spinning Reel? 8 Important Questions You Should be Asking

1. What Kind Of Fish Will You Be Catching?

The first thing to consider is the type of fish you’re planning to catch. If your average catch will be small to medium sized, a spinning reel is the best choice. If you’re going to be tackling large fish, however, you should opt for a baitcaster.

2. Which Lures and Lines Do I Need?

Next, you’ll need to consider which line you’re planning to use. If you’re opting for a line with around 10lbs, a spinning reel is the best choice since it gives you the bendiness and flexibility you require to guard against the line breaking. However, if you’re going to use heavy lures and lines, a baitcaster will give you the better control you need.

fishing on a lake
3. Are You a Beginner?

If you’re new to angling, you don’t want to have to set up complex gear. That means a spinning reel is the best choice for you. Handling a baitcaster will take effort and time, so it’s considered to be a reel designed for more advanced anglers.

4. How Important is Accuracy?

If accuracy is very important to you, avoid a spinning reel. It simply won’t deliver the level of accuracy and control an experienced angler required. A baitcaster gives you casting accuracy since you can aim for your chosen spot then hit it each and every time.

5. What About Maintenance?

You’ll need to maintain your fishing gear properly to get as much use from it as possible. This means you’ll need to disassemble the reel regularly and clean its components before greasing its teeth, oiling its bearing and reassembling it. A baitcaster will have a structure which is more complex than a spinning reel, and this means that maintenance takes longer with a baitcaster.

spinning reel close up shot
6. Are You on a Budget?

It will depend on which unit you choose, however in general a spinning reel will be cheaper than a baitcaster. On the other hand, though, spinning reels are less durable. If your budget is tight, you’ll probably want to go for a spinning reel but if you’re looking for long-term value, a baitcaster could be a better purchase overall.

7. How important is Durability?

When you need a reel with a long shelf life, a baitcaster is a good choice. With its more complex construction, it’s more durable and sturdy than a spinning reel.

8. Tangling and Jamming – What You Should Know

Nothing is more disruptive to an angling experience than tangling and jamming. While it’s going to inevitably happen from time to time, you’ll want to minimize the chances of it occurring.

If you’re a newbie to angling, this is especially going to be a concern. While no gear can guarantee no breaking or tangling, a spinning reel is a better choice since it doesn’t tend to jam.

spinning reel model

Other Important Points

There are three other elements which are important when it comes to deciding between a spinning reel and a baitcaster. 

First is the line capacity. A baitcaster will usually have a bigger line capacity when compared to a spinning reel.

Next is the casting distance. Again, baitcasters will have a larger casting distance. On the other hand, though, a spinning reel will be easier to cast to reach maximum range.

Finally, the gear ratio is also important. Baitcasters have a wider variety of ratios to choose from.

man spin fishing

When Should I Use a Baitcaster?

There are certain angling situations in which a baitcaster is the right choice. If you’re using a heavier line or lure, a baitcaster is the best choice. It will give you more control and accuracy, which is ideal for a more advanced angler.

Baitcasters offer the following advantages and disadvantages:

The Pros and Cons of Baitcasters

Pros

  • Less line twisting
  • Easier to slow down the bait
  • Better accuracy when using a heavy lure
  • Better control and accuracy
  • More gear ratios available
  • Light reel weight
  • Better line capacity
  • Greater durability
  • Better for use in harsh weather
  • Better for catching larger fish
  • Best for saltwater fishing

Cons

  • Takes some time and practice to learn how to use it
  • Wears out light lines
  • More complex maintenance
  • More costly to purchase
  • Not ideal for beginners
  • Jamming is more common

When Should I Use a Spinning Reel?

Spinning reels are a great choice when you’re catching small or medium-sized fish. The spool is fixed under the rod so it’s the weight of the lure, tackle and bait which pulls out the line.

If your line will be under 10lbs, a spinning reel is best. The main advantages and disadvantages of this reel type include:

The Pros and Cons of Spinning Reels

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Less tangling
  • Fairly affordable
  • Longer line life
  • Less jamming
  • Easy maintenance
  • Suitable for all styles of fishing
  • Ideal for light lines and lures
  • No line digging
  • Ideal for freshwater fishing
  • Eliminates backlash
  • Can cast above plants and under trees

Cons

  • Less line capacity
  • Heavier, larger reels
  • Incapable of handling stronger, larger fish
  • Less control and accuracy
  • Hard to slow down bait
  • Doesn’t pitch or flip easily
  • Small range of gear ratios available
  • Inaccurate with a heavy lure


Making a Choice

When it comes to choosing between a spinning reel and a baitcaster, there are a few things to bear in mind. 

If you’re an experienced or intermediate angler who wants better accuracy and wants to catch larger fish, a baitcaster is the best choice.

However, if you’re a beginner angler who wants to go freshwater fishing, a spinning reel is a good option for you. 

Hopefully, this article will give you all the information you need to make an informed choice about whether a baitcaster or spinning reel is the right choice for your angling needs. 

Make sure to leave us a comment down below!

Leave a reply